Daily DispatchDaily Dispatch

South Africa still heading for a fiscal cliff, warns investment bank

South Africa’s debt levels are going to remain on an “unsustainable path” despite the government’s intentions to cut spending, Bank of America Securities said on Wednesday

Picture: 123RF/ SETSIRI SILAPASUWAANCHAI

South Africa’s debt levels are going to remain on an “unsustainable path” despite the government’s intentions to cut spending, Bank of America Securities said on Wednesday.

A “lack of policy co-ordination, tax revenue shortfalls and very high execution risks” mean government is unlikely to achieve the ambitious spending cuts outlined in the recent supplementary budget, the investment bank’s South Africa economist, Rukayat Yusuf, said.

The investment bank — which expects the economy to contract by 10.3% and shed 1-million jobs in 2020 — said that state debt as a percentage of GDP will breach 100% in the coming three years. This is on par with the government’s worst-case — or “passive” — scenario outlined in the budget in June.

The outlook for South Africa’s recovery later this year is weighed down by what it sees as a limited economic stimulus package when compared with developed countries such as the US and UK, as well as load-shedding and stricter social distancing regulations.

“We see growth remaining lower for longer,” Yusuf said.

Central to its expectations of a weaker recover in SA is the “permanent removal of economic capacity”, which will come in the form of “industry space rationalisation, job losses and business closures”, said Michael Jacks, head of SA research at the bank.  

South Africa entered the Covid-19 crisis with less fiscal headroom to provide support and much weaker economic fundamentals compared with other regions, Jacks said. “Unfortunately, this is being intensified by stricter and protracted lockdown measures,” he said.

Beleaguered state-owned enterprises (SOEs) pose additional headwinds for the fiscus, noted Yusuf. Pressure on the Treasury to fund the business rescue plan of SAA signalled there may be more support for SOEs in future, including the Land Bank, which defaulted on its debt in April, as well as the “big elephant in the room”, Eskom.

The bank’s most recent survey of South Africa fund managers reflected a similar pessimism about government’s ability to get a handle on its finances.

According to the survey, 60% of managers expect South Africa will reach a “fiscal cliff” — whereby it takes on too much debt and will require assistance from external agencies — within the next five years. A mere 13% of managers see evidence of any government reform.

All three credit ratings agencies have expressed similar doubts that South Africa will be able to deliver on the cuts envisaged in the supplementary budget. These come on top of the R160bn in wage cuts envisaged in the February budget, which are being steadfastly resisted by public sector labour unions.