More funeral policies are sold in South Africa than any other form of insurance, but in many cases claims are not paid by the time the funerals must be held, meaning the grieving family has to loan money, at huge interest rates, to pay for it.
The Covid-19 pandemic has made things a whole lot worse.
South Africa has one of the highest Covid-19 death tolls in the world, with “excess deaths” — the difference in the total number of deaths in a crisis compared to those expected under normal conditions — exceeding 220,000.
In terms of the Policyholder Protection Rules issued under the Long-Term Insurance Act, from the time a valid claim is lodged, with all the required documents, an insurer has just two business days to assess it and authorise payment.
But that requirement is being widely flouted to the frustration of the families, intermediaries and undertakers.
Sindiswa of Protea Glen, Soweto wrote to me last month about her battle with B3, a licensed financial services provider, over her funeral policy claim.
On its website, B3 makes a very bold statement about its commitment to clients.
“Before B3, the funeral business was very demoralising, heartbreaking and never perceived to be a professional industry by anyone involved in the funeral process.
“B3 is here to bring the spirit of Ubuntu to the funeral service and assurance industry in SA.”
The funeral policies it sells are underwritten by licensed insurer African Unity Life (AUL).
Sindiswa took out the funeral policy, via B3, on August 1 last year, covering herself and her husband, as well as her elderly aunt, for the amount of R30,000 each.
Her monthly premium was R489, of which R375 covered the aunt, who died on August 29 this year.
Five days later, having sourced all the required documentation, Sindiswa submitted a claim. It was approved shortly after that, but the expected payment didn’t materialise.
The funeral had to go ahead regardless, so she was forced to borrow money from relatives.
But in the days that followed, there was still no payment.
In an email sent to Sindiswa by a B3 representative on September 13, she was told: “We currently have a backlog on our claims because we are experiencing high volumes since the Covid-19 pandemic, plus a change in underwriters, and due to that we are currently unable to keep to the 48 working hours turnaround that B3 has kept over the years.”
Both the company’s Facebook page as well as complaints website HelloPeter feature many posts by other B3 clients, complaining of lack of payment of their valid claims.
One woman said she’d been made to wait three months for her payment.
On September 22 — the date is significant — I sent a media query to B3, asking how many days or weeks B3 takes to pay claims on average.
When the response finally came, it was essentially a pass-the-buck.
There was no regret expressed for the plight of Sindiswa or any other clients, just this: “The underwriter makes the final decision on payments of claims and by when claims should be settled, (so) this question can be referred to the underwriter (AUL) directly.”
So much for ubuntu.
I also questioned a HelloPeter post alleging that B3’s clients had their premiums increased this year, contrary to the Financial Sector Conduct Authority’s (FSCA) view on the matter.
I was told that “only” clients over the age of 75 have had their funeral policy premiums increased.
Last month, the regulator said it “notes with concern” the high premium increases that are being implemented by insurers on funeral policies throughout the industry.
“It is the view of the FSCA that premiums must be priced correctly at the inception of the policy so that any increases which may be implemented would still result in fair outcomes for policyholders and the policy continuing to perform as expected.”
The FSCA warned that insurers should not use Covid as a reason to make up for historically too-low premiums which were “consciously based on overly optimistic assumptions”.
I emailed AUL about the matter but got no response, despite a follow-up email. Finally on October 7 I got an email from AUL claims assessor Johan Skors, apologising for the delayed reply and apologising to Sindiswa for “any inconvenience caused due to the delay in payment”.
Ah, that catch all “inconvenience” sorry. How very convenient.
He claimed that Sindiswa’s claim was paid on September 22, the day I raised the issue with B3.
Not so, she says, that R30,000 was only paid into her account on October 1, and she has an SMS to prove it.
“Unfortunately,” Skors said, “the delay in payment was caused by high volumes of claims, felt by most in the industry.”
A spike in claims volumes big enough to justify paying claims after 18 business days instead of two?
The FSCA confirmed to me that it has also received complaints about B3 and underwriter AUL not settling funeral claims timeously and said it would be engaging with both companies about the issue.
Two years ago the family of Sifiso Mtshali dumped his body at Old Mutual’s offices in KwaDukuza on the KZN North Coast, in protest at the insurer’s failure to keep their payment promise.
Given the current delays, I wouldn’t be at all surprised if other families resort to similar desperate measures to draw attention to their plight.
• If you’ve been saddled with a funeral policy increase that’s not allowed for in your policy document, or you’ve been waiting weeks for a funeral claim to be paid, despite submitting all the required documentation, lodge a complaint with the FSCA. Email: complaints@fsca.co.za